Simulation for Designers - Part 3

Simulation for Designers - Part 3

Stress Singularities

Stress singularities are a major headache when analysing results as they considerably distort results! They are also a main cause for non-convergence of results. Which can further lead to lack of confidence in results and in extreme cases not using simulation at all.

So, what is stress singularity and why does it occur even in the simplest of designs and models?

This can be best explained by the above simple bracket example which shows a high localised stress around the force applied on a point. This stress can be considerably higher than the operational stress and applying a denser mesh around this simply leads to a much higher stress. This phenomenon is known as stress singularity where the stress can become infinite, as illustrated by the following formula;

Therefore, to avoid stress singularities when applying loads, it is recommended not to apply loads at points and small edges. Stress Singularities can also occur by applying constraints on points and small edges – even faces with sharp corners as illustrated here.

Finally, another cause of stress singularity is over-simplification of components as illustrated below.

In this example, the fillets have been removed to simplify the analysis; however, when we keep refining the mesh, the maximum stress value does not converge as all the stress is concentrated around the edge, as shown above. In this scenario it would be advisable to un-suppress the fillets to help distribute the load more uniformly as shown below.

Over-time and with experience it will become easier and easier to interrogate results of models and designs with stress singularities present.

Nastran In-CAD provides a comprehensive set of post-processing results that can help you gain more confidence when analysing results. 

If you would to watch some of the videos I have created around Autodesk Simulation then please take a look at our Simulation webinar library.

Kirjoittaja

Wasim Younis

An Autodesk simulation solutions manager with more than 30 years of experience in the manufacturing field, including working at Rolls Royce and British Aerospace. Wasim has been involved with Autodesk simulation software from when it was first introduced, and is well-known throughout the Autodesk simulation community, worldwide. He has also authored the Up and Running with Autodesk Inventor Professional and Inventor Nastran books. He also runs a dedicated forum for Autodesk simulation users on LinkedIn – Up and Running with Autodesk Simulation.